A phone mount fails in one of three ways: the phone falls out, the mount falls off, or the mount turns out to be illegal where you drive. The third is decided by local law rather than by the product, so check it before buying. The first two come down to where the mount is fixed and how it holds the device.
Vent mounts: fastest to fit, with one real drawback
A vent mount clips to the air vent blade and takes four seconds to fit. It puts the screen roughly level with the road, and it needs no adhesive, so nothing is left behind when the car is sold. The drawback is heat: in summer the vent blows hot air into the back of a phone that is also running GPS, and phones throttle when they get hot.
The Foldable Magnetic Air Vent Mount ($10.99) is the plain magnetic design and folds flat when it is not in use. The Magnetic Air Vent Holder with Rotating Magnet ($11.75) adds a full pivot, which matters if the vent blade points somewhere unhelpful.
Both need a metal plate on the phone or case. If you would rather not have one, the Universal Vent and Dashboard Mount ($10.99) grips the phone by its edges instead and works with any case, though it is slower to dock one-handed.
Dashboard: steadier, and kinder to the phone
A dashboard mount sits away from the vent, so it avoids the heat problem, and a suction base on a flat dash is mechanically more stable than a clip on a thin vent blade. What it costs is placement: it needs a genuinely flat area, and a curved or heavily grained dash will defeat a suction cup inside a week.
The Universal Dashboard Bracket ($12.35) is the plain choice. The Foldable Suction Cup Holder ($12.92) is the one to look at if the same mount has to hold a phone one day and a tablet or GPS unit the next - it is built for the heavier device, and that shows in how it behaves over speed bumps.
Wireless charging, which changes the trade
A mount that charges the phone removes the cable, which is the single most annoying part of using GPS in a car. The Magnetic 15W Wireless Charger ($24.99) bends to the shape of the dash and holds by magnet while charging; the Infrared Induction Wireless Charger ($24.99) opens its arms as the phone approaches, which is the version that works properly with one hand.
Two things to check: whether your phone supports magnetic wireless charging at all, and whether a thick case reduces it to a trickle. Both are common and neither is obvious from the listing.
The back seat, which most lists forget
For passengers the headrest position is the only sensible one, and it is what turns a phone into something usable rather than something held. The Magnetic Seat Back Holder with Suction Mount ($10.99) fixes to the rear of the front headrest and puts the screen at eye level for whoever is behind it.
What to check before you order
Three things decide whether a mount is any use: whether the vent blade you have is horizontal or vertical, whether your phone case is thick enough to defeat a magnet, and whether the mount can be reached without your hand leaving the wheel. The last one is what separates a mount you use from one that ends up in a drawer.